Home Players ask Players

We need new Moderators!


ModeratorWe are always on the lookout for talented people to join the team. That means you! If you think you could help us organise and inform the community while entertaining everyone then apply. We need people to help out on the forum, behind the scenes with announcements, on Discord and on our other Social Media channels.


If this is something you think might be of interest to you, HERE

Should RVs lost to starvation be returned?

We are starting to see more situations where a member captures an open RV, just to be told later that day or the next that the player lost his RV due to starvation. In the past we had returned those RVs. Today we don't think we should do all the work capturing open RVs and give them up because some players do not know how to manage their food. Please excuse me if I sound rude.

Should RVs lost to starvation be returned or should they be considered abandoned? 

Thoughts?

Comments

  • Shadow_21 (AU1)Shadow_21 (AU1) AU1 Posts: 1,370
    all depends on how u fell basically lol....if you fell like sticking up for yourself taking a stand and saying "no im keeping it" go for it...but they have everyeright to take it from you, they always have the right to take it from u or anyone....because its a player made rule....there are a few things u need to think about though....1. if they are a strong alliance or really anybody with an army, they will most definitely hit you out of anger, they will also try to take back the rv regardless of wether you let them or not....2. put yourself in their shoes...if you were too lose an rv due to starvation you would be happy if someone gave it back to you, wouldn't u

                                                                                    Made by me using word
                                                                 <======|===O*SHADOW*O=========>
  • I would ask myself to following questions:


    1 How big is the alliance that asked for the return of the RV and how big are they in relation to my own alliance

    2 How far is the RV to my castle. If the RV is closer to your castle than it is to the castle of the person asking for return of the RV you should be able to hold the RV.

    3 Think of what the starvation could have caused. If a maintance caused it, it would be good to give it back. Otherwise it's just the dumb fault of the player. Than I would not consider giving it back out of kindness.


    Kind regards

    Lucas1999

    Hello everyone!

    Good to see you. I'm Lucas from the dutch server (NL1) and i play in an amazing Alliance called Two Towers. I really enjoy playing the game. If you want to make contact with me leave a message here or if you are from the dutch server message me there!

    Kind regards Lucas1999



  • Personally, I think there are way too many cry babies in this game. Bum humping about RV's. I find they used to find them in the wastes all the time and people always messaged me about them. Stating, in some way that some how in the magical powers of this Game an Open RV is somehow actually there's. Even had people try and state this during spawns or actually try to CAP the RV I just captured from a spawn and message leaders pretending it's there RV and I stole from them. Even though I actually watched my TROOPS GET TO IT FIRST. And, then I had to prove I didn't steal it by screen shot.  With the same things not expected of them.  If you hold the RV it's YOUR RV rules of the game are simple. An OPEN RV is an OPEN RV. RV's are actually meant to be fought over. That's how this game was built. Too many people are too afraid of war to actually play this war game the way it was designed. I hope someday a real alliance comes along in this games and wants me to join its ranks. 

    Thank god you're not talking about outposts getting stolen.... Been a hot button issue with me as of late.
    Current Member of The Un~Forgiven (Self Appointed Propagandist)
    Former Proud Member of HITMEN(formerly know as Grumpy Hitmen)
    Former Proud Member of The Ninja Pack, Rastafarians, Rustlin' Jimmies, KingdonOfDeath and Strike Force
    Proud former Recruiter for The Ninja Pack - Crimson Warriors
    And, a very brief Period Of Time in Neph Reapers(Please don't tell The MISC)


    https://prnt.sc/immx03
    Making a run for first and your...
    https://prnt.sc/imuxgc
    Then You...
    https://prnt.sc/imupnu
    FML


    HIVE Club leader and Creator
    http://prntscr.com/fz0jgz
    http://prntscr.com/fyowm1

    GGE Courting Methods
    https://community.goodgamestudios.com/empire/en/discussion/358319/bullies#latest
    Well at least. She Posted on my wall.

    I am also a self-appointed GGE historian. Back in the day, I was in the Original "Honey Badgers". Until it became part of the fellowship. And, my character fell into ashes over a long hospital stay. And, the use of "xXx" at the beginning and end of the of your name was removed along with my Character. I've been here from the Start B***hes.


  • OxO (AU1)OxO (AU1) AU1 Posts: 962
    If it happened to you, would you want it back?

    Yes, yes you would. You'd also probably want to burn the cunt so I mean say no at your own risk



  • i would give it back, food situations can be hard to deal with i wake up an dlog in every day with 20k food left in all castles so if somehing were to happen fto not enable me to get on to loot quickly so troops dont starve then i would want rvs back defo 


    anyways if you keep a  certain soldier in there i cant remember which one but you wont lose your rvs to starvation as certain troops starve first, can anyone confirm this? 
    It's how it works. You lose the higher food consuming troops first. It's how the machine works. The lower the food consumption the better off your RV will be. I don't understand how people lose RVs to starvation. I used this logic and it has never happened to me.
    Current Member of The Un~Forgiven (Self Appointed Propagandist)
    Former Proud Member of HITMEN(formerly know as Grumpy Hitmen)
    Former Proud Member of The Ninja Pack, Rastafarians, Rustlin' Jimmies, KingdonOfDeath and Strike Force
    Proud former Recruiter for The Ninja Pack - Crimson Warriors
    And, a very brief Period Of Time in Neph Reapers(Please don't tell The MISC)


    https://prnt.sc/immx03
    Making a run for first and your...
    https://prnt.sc/imuxgc
    Then You...
    https://prnt.sc/imupnu
    FML


    HIVE Club leader and Creator
    http://prntscr.com/fz0jgz
    http://prntscr.com/fyowm1

    GGE Courting Methods
    https://community.goodgamestudios.com/empire/en/discussion/358319/bullies#latest
    Well at least. She Posted on my wall.

    I am also a self-appointed GGE historian. Back in the day, I was in the Original "Honey Badgers". Until it became part of the fellowship. And, my character fell into ashes over a long hospital stay. And, the use of "xXx" at the beginning and end of the of your name was removed along with my Character. I've been here from the Start B***hes.


  • Manage your food so you dont famine your RVs.

    I famine in outers all the time and have never lost any RVs due to it.

    Depends on the alliance, if they're going to shank you and take it anyway you may as well surrender it and save yourself the trouble, otherwise it makes a nice excuse for a war
    Friedrich IV US1
    The Prodigal Scrub Returns
  • Just don't over-saturate.. I believe RVs don't starve unless all the troops in your castle starve first. That's how RTs work, as long as your production is more than the consumption of the troops stationed there, it will not starve if you famine
    Friedrich IV US1
    The Prodigal Scrub Returns
  • MinosMinos Posts: 80
    I've had this happen to me but i was able to cap the RV back in time. You can lose the RV if you only have attackers in the castle or if all your defence are in RVs.

    P.s. moved to players ask players as not bug in this issue, desertions are working as intended here.
  • This is a war game, returning property is just a waste of time/resources imo.
Sign In to comment.