Home English (UK) Players ask Players

We need new Moderators!


ModeratorWe are always on the lookout for talented people to join the team. That means you! If you think you could help us organise and inform the community while entertaining everyone then apply. We need people to help out on the forum, behind the scenes with announcements, on Discord and on our other Social Media channels.


If this is something you think might be of interest to you, HERE

Defense Calculator

I have created my own defense calculator
This will help anyone to set their defense up properly when they have incoming
It will tell you the percentage of troops that need to be kept on each wall, and the melee/ranged ratio
I have placed this calculator on our website, http://legionmarauder.yolasite.com/
Anyone can use it when they want, it is saved as an excel spreadsheet, and is free to use
I used to use this calculator: http://ggempire.wikidot.com/phuc-em
but it isn't working anymore. It has made me make many losses, and sometimes says I can win on a wall when I can't, and it also doesn't have all the troops
The calculator I have made includes ALL of the troops, and is much more accurate
Please can I have feedback on it?
Thank you
Juvster

Also, so far, it only does when defending on the wall with Halbs and Longbowmen, I will add when defending with vets, kingsguards etc. later, hopefully by tomorrow

Feedback so far please?
King Juvster the Fearless




PROUD NON-RUBY PLAYER ON INTERNATIONAL1!!!

Leader of Ghost Marauders on International1 - Level 20 alliance
http://ghostmarauders.yolasite.com/

Vice Duke at level 39
Archduke at level 41
Prince at level 49
King at level 53
the Unyielding at level 55
the Great at level 56
the Conqueror at level 59
the Terrible at level 64
the Merciless at level 64
the Victorious at level 64
the Steel-hearted at level 64
the Resolute at level 64
the Furious at level 66

That Synchronisation


That UNBELIEVABLE weekly loot: http://prntscr.com/9j3jd7

THE POWER OF NON-RUBY PLAYERS:

http://prntscr.com/9s8yrn
«1

Comments

  • if it really works, then it sounds great, but it can not account for everything. i did not see anything about gem bonus's in the crtyrd, so even if i win a defense on the wall, it might only be on 1 flank, and the attacker then sends his 6 wave hit with 80% bonus into my crtyrd and destroys another 3K of my men. so it looks great, but only helps for the wall portion of the battle.

    that means that if his troops get past the wall, he can still do major damage. maybe it would be better to fire caste rather then lose troops. maybe if you use a different castellan you would get better results

    if i missed the gem part let me know. there was a lot of stuff floating on those pages and its possible i missed it, but as far as i saw it did not include gems

    but the biggest issue is that looks like a big and complicated book, with little fill-in boxes everywhere, but im not sure if all of them need to be filled in or some need to stay at default mode. maybe if you did a step-by step showing exactly what boxes need to be filled in?

    also, like you said, its only based on defending with certain troops. what if i have flame bearers or nomad or some other special troop in my defenses? that changes the calculations completely.
    im batman
    furture @ EN1
  • if it really works, then it sounds great, but it can not account for everything. i did not see anything about gem bonus's in the crtyrd, so even if i win a defense on the wall, it might only be on 1 flank, and the attacker then sends his 6 wave hit with 80% bonus into my crtyrd and destroys another 3K of my men. so it looks great, but only helps for the wall portion of the battle.
    That was the point, it was only supposed to be for the wall to setup your defense, not for keep battles etc., so gems are not needed. So I did not include gems, no

    but the biggest issue is that looks like a big and complicated book, with little fill-in boxes everywhere, but im not sure if all of them need to be filled in or some need to stay at default mode. maybe if you did a step-by step showing exactly what boxes need to be filled in?
    Fair enough, but it is colour coded to show what you need to fill in and what you don't, and there is a page on how to use it as well in case you get stuck. But yes, it is a bit messy, I need to fix that up, thanks

    also, like you said, its only based on defending with certain troops. what if i have flame bearers or nomad or some other special troop in my defenses? that changes the calculations completely.
    I did say I will add all that in later, hopefully by tomorrow.
    King Juvster the Fearless




    PROUD NON-RUBY PLAYER ON INTERNATIONAL1!!!

    Leader of Ghost Marauders on International1 - Level 20 alliance
    http://ghostmarauders.yolasite.com/

    Vice Duke at level 39
    Archduke at level 41
    Prince at level 49
    King at level 53
    the Unyielding at level 55
    the Great at level 56
    the Conqueror at level 59
    the Terrible at level 64
    the Merciless at level 64
    the Victorious at level 64
    the Steel-hearted at level 64
    the Resolute at level 64
    the Furious at level 66

    That Synchronisation


    That UNBELIEVABLE weekly loot: http://prntscr.com/9j3jd7

    THE POWER OF NON-RUBY PLAYERS:

    http://prntscr.com/9s8yrn
  • i just thought that since it was a defense calculator it took the whole battle into effect, not just the walls
    That was the point, it was only supposed to be for the wall to setup your defense, not for keep battles etc., so gems are not needed. So I did not include gems, no

    yeah i saw the color code and stuff, but its still pretty big and confusing and messy. if i learned how to do it, i could do it no problem, its just that it looks like learning it will take a while
    Fair enough, but it is colour coded to show what you need to fill in and what you don't, and there is a page on how to use it as well in case you get stuck. But yes, it is a bit messy, I need to fix that up, thanks

    i knew you said something about a few vets and KG, i was not sure if you meant just those or if you were going to add every other defense troop
    I did say I will add all that in later, hopefully by tomorrow.

    im batman
    furture @ EN1
  • i just thought that since it was a defense calculator it took the whole battle into effect, not just the walls
    Yeah, sorry, no, it is only for wall battles, not the whole battle

    yeah i saw the color code and stuff, but its still pretty big and confusing and messy. if i learned how to do it, i could do it no problem, its just that it looks like learning it will take a while
    As you said, once you get used to it it is actually extremely easy to use, but it is a bit of a mess, I will fix that up

    i knew you said something about a few vets and KG, i was not sure if you meant just those or if you were going to add every other defense troop
    I will add vet spearmen and bowmen, kingsguard, flame bearer and and it's ranged one, their vets, and vet halbs and longbowmen.


    King Juvster the Fearless




    PROUD NON-RUBY PLAYER ON INTERNATIONAL1!!!

    Leader of Ghost Marauders on International1 - Level 20 alliance
    http://ghostmarauders.yolasite.com/

    Vice Duke at level 39
    Archduke at level 41
    Prince at level 49
    King at level 53
    the Unyielding at level 55
    the Great at level 56
    the Conqueror at level 59
    the Terrible at level 64
    the Merciless at level 64
    the Victorious at level 64
    the Steel-hearted at level 64
    the Resolute at level 64
    the Furious at level 66

    That Synchronisation


    That UNBELIEVABLE weekly loot: http://prntscr.com/9j3jd7

    THE POWER OF NON-RUBY PLAYERS:

    http://prntscr.com/9s8yrn
  • I have told my alliance members of this 'defense calculator' and will try and give you some feedback if possible.



    KJ

    Incredible:D

    King Jupiter Lvl 38, Prince King Jupiter The Ravager , TeamXtreme (used to be Bemrose UK), 2305 honour (top of the honour rankings)  B) 

    Non-Ruby Buyer                                                      Watchtower lvl 1 and Bakery lvl 2 in my main XD
  • I have told my alliance members of this 'defense calculator' and will try and give you some feedback if possible.



    KJ
    thank you so much :)
    King Juvster the Fearless




    PROUD NON-RUBY PLAYER ON INTERNATIONAL1!!!

    Leader of Ghost Marauders on International1 - Level 20 alliance
    http://ghostmarauders.yolasite.com/

    Vice Duke at level 39
    Archduke at level 41
    Prince at level 49
    King at level 53
    the Unyielding at level 55
    the Great at level 56
    the Conqueror at level 59
    the Terrible at level 64
    the Merciless at level 64
    the Victorious at level 64
    the Steel-hearted at level 64
    the Resolute at level 64
    the Furious at level 66

    That Synchronisation


    That UNBELIEVABLE weekly loot: http://prntscr.com/9j3jd7

    THE POWER OF NON-RUBY PLAYERS:

    http://prntscr.com/9s8yrn
  • I have now added when defending on the wall with vets as well
    Also, I have removed all the mess, and it is much easier to understand now, and is not in a mess anymore, it is nice and neat now
    King Juvster the Fearless




    PROUD NON-RUBY PLAYER ON INTERNATIONAL1!!!

    Leader of Ghost Marauders on International1 - Level 20 alliance
    http://ghostmarauders.yolasite.com/

    Vice Duke at level 39
    Archduke at level 41
    Prince at level 49
    King at level 53
    the Unyielding at level 55
    the Great at level 56
    the Conqueror at level 59
    the Terrible at level 64
    the Merciless at level 64
    the Victorious at level 64
    the Steel-hearted at level 64
    the Resolute at level 64
    the Furious at level 66

    That Synchronisation


    That UNBELIEVABLE weekly loot: http://prntscr.com/9j3jd7

    THE POWER OF NON-RUBY PLAYERS:

    http://prntscr.com/9s8yrn
  • Also added in Kingsguard troops now
    Just go on the site, http://legionmarauder.yolasite.com/
    to see it
    King Juvster the Fearless




    PROUD NON-RUBY PLAYER ON INTERNATIONAL1!!!

    Leader of Ghost Marauders on International1 - Level 20 alliance
    http://ghostmarauders.yolasite.com/

    Vice Duke at level 39
    Archduke at level 41
    Prince at level 49
    King at level 53
    the Unyielding at level 55
    the Great at level 56
    the Conqueror at level 59
    the Terrible at level 64
    the Merciless at level 64
    the Victorious at level 64
    the Steel-hearted at level 64
    the Resolute at level 64
    the Furious at level 66

    That Synchronisation


    That UNBELIEVABLE weekly loot: http://prntscr.com/9j3jd7

    THE POWER OF NON-RUBY PLAYERS:

    http://prntscr.com/9s8yrn
  • Have added in flame bearers and composite bowmen now as well
    Also fixed a little bug that had come up

    Has anyone used it as yet and would like to give feedback?
    King Juvster the Fearless




    PROUD NON-RUBY PLAYER ON INTERNATIONAL1!!!

    Leader of Ghost Marauders on International1 - Level 20 alliance
    http://ghostmarauders.yolasite.com/

    Vice Duke at level 39
    Archduke at level 41
    Prince at level 49
    King at level 53
    the Unyielding at level 55
    the Great at level 56
    the Conqueror at level 59
    the Terrible at level 64
    the Merciless at level 64
    the Victorious at level 64
    the Steel-hearted at level 64
    the Resolute at level 64
    the Furious at level 66

    That Synchronisation


    That UNBELIEVABLE weekly loot: http://prntscr.com/9j3jd7

    THE POWER OF NON-RUBY PLAYERS:

    http://prntscr.com/9s8yrn
  • Yes, one of my alliance members says it's helpful but may not be accurate enough, but he also said it should give a rough idea of how a battle will turn out. I will use the defense calculator when a baron next attacks me and I will see how good it is then notify you

    KJ

    Incredible:D

    King Jupiter Lvl 38, Prince King Jupiter The Ravager , TeamXtreme (used to be Bemrose UK), 2305 honour (top of the honour rankings)  B) 

    Non-Ruby Buyer                                                      Watchtower lvl 1 and Bakery lvl 2 in my main XD
  • Any feedback from anyone as yet???

    I was attacked by a foreign just now, and used to calculator myself to see if it would work
    It told me my defense setup, and what percentage of melee troops I should place on the wall
    So i tried
    And:



    Left:


    Center:
    No battle

    Right:


    It saved me A LOT of losses on the wall, because i would have defended on 1 flank only without the calculator

    But as some people said, it is only for wall battles, and doesn't take the keep into account, so:


    Ouch, a lot of losses, so i might try to introduce a keep battle calculator as well
    But still, without this calculator, i would have lost all my troops, so it still helped A LOT, and my result proves it to be accurate
    King Juvster the Fearless




    PROUD NON-RUBY PLAYER ON INTERNATIONAL1!!!

    Leader of Ghost Marauders on International1 - Level 20 alliance
    http://ghostmarauders.yolasite.com/

    Vice Duke at level 39
    Archduke at level 41
    Prince at level 49
    King at level 53
    the Unyielding at level 55
    the Great at level 56
    the Conqueror at level 59
    the Terrible at level 64
    the Merciless at level 64
    the Victorious at level 64
    the Steel-hearted at level 64
    the Resolute at level 64
    the Furious at level 66

    That Synchronisation


    That UNBELIEVABLE weekly loot: http://prntscr.com/9j3jd7

    THE POWER OF NON-RUBY PLAYERS:

    http://prntscr.com/9s8yrn
  • anyone got any feedback as yet?
    King Juvster the Fearless




    PROUD NON-RUBY PLAYER ON INTERNATIONAL1!!!

    Leader of Ghost Marauders on International1 - Level 20 alliance
    http://ghostmarauders.yolasite.com/

    Vice Duke at level 39
    Archduke at level 41
    Prince at level 49
    King at level 53
    the Unyielding at level 55
    the Great at level 56
    the Conqueror at level 59
    the Terrible at level 64
    the Merciless at level 64
    the Victorious at level 64
    the Steel-hearted at level 64
    the Resolute at level 64
    the Furious at level 66

    That Synchronisation


    That UNBELIEVABLE weekly loot: http://prntscr.com/9j3jd7

    THE POWER OF NON-RUBY PLAYERS:

    http://prntscr.com/9s8yrn
  • I used it again and the results:



    has anyone else used it as yet?
    King Juvster the Fearless




    PROUD NON-RUBY PLAYER ON INTERNATIONAL1!!!

    Leader of Ghost Marauders on International1 - Level 20 alliance
    http://ghostmarauders.yolasite.com/

    Vice Duke at level 39
    Archduke at level 41
    Prince at level 49
    King at level 53
    the Unyielding at level 55
    the Great at level 56
    the Conqueror at level 59
    the Terrible at level 64
    the Merciless at level 64
    the Victorious at level 64
    the Steel-hearted at level 64
    the Resolute at level 64
    the Furious at level 66

    That Synchronisation


    That UNBELIEVABLE weekly loot: http://prntscr.com/9j3jd7

    THE POWER OF NON-RUBY PLAYERS:

    http://prntscr.com/9s8yrn
  • you must add raven chompers pumpkin butchers.
  • Just used the calculator again

    Results:



    So yeah, it works quite well
    King Juvster the Fearless




    PROUD NON-RUBY PLAYER ON INTERNATIONAL1!!!

    Leader of Ghost Marauders on International1 - Level 20 alliance
    http://ghostmarauders.yolasite.com/

    Vice Duke at level 39
    Archduke at level 41
    Prince at level 49
    King at level 53
    the Unyielding at level 55
    the Great at level 56
    the Conqueror at level 59
    the Terrible at level 64
    the Merciless at level 64
    the Victorious at level 64
    the Steel-hearted at level 64
    the Resolute at level 64
    the Furious at level 66

    That Synchronisation


    That UNBELIEVABLE weekly loot: http://prntscr.com/9j3jd7

    THE POWER OF NON-RUBY PLAYERS:

    http://prntscr.com/9s8yrn
  • Relis (ASIA1)Relis (ASIA1) Posts: 1,402
    Did you added Frost bowmans,bone huntress,master soldiers of them.
    A Proud Member Asian Sensation.Which is a sub of Drunken Fist (But now we looks like a restaurant).
    18th in berimond invasion without buying rubies or having a bakery.
    Most active member of Asian Sensation.
    I always be alone in alliance chat like 3-4 hours :D
  • no, because they are all temporary and have equivalent strengths to other soldiers in the game, so no point
    King Juvster the Fearless




    PROUD NON-RUBY PLAYER ON INTERNATIONAL1!!!

    Leader of Ghost Marauders on International1 - Level 20 alliance
    http://ghostmarauders.yolasite.com/

    Vice Duke at level 39
    Archduke at level 41
    Prince at level 49
    King at level 53
    the Unyielding at level 55
    the Great at level 56
    the Conqueror at level 59
    the Terrible at level 64
    the Merciless at level 64
    the Victorious at level 64
    the Steel-hearted at level 64
    the Resolute at level 64
    the Furious at level 66

    That Synchronisation


    That UNBELIEVABLE weekly loot: http://prntscr.com/9j3jd7

    THE POWER OF NON-RUBY PLAYERS:

    http://prntscr.com/9s8yrn
  • The calculator doesnt open for me :/
    championabrar @ US1 
  • The calculator doesnt open for me :/
    Do you have microsoft excel installed on your computer?
    King Juvster the Fearless




    PROUD NON-RUBY PLAYER ON INTERNATIONAL1!!!

    Leader of Ghost Marauders on International1 - Level 20 alliance
    http://ghostmarauders.yolasite.com/

    Vice Duke at level 39
    Archduke at level 41
    Prince at level 49
    King at level 53
    the Unyielding at level 55
    the Great at level 56
    the Conqueror at level 59
    the Terrible at level 64
    the Merciless at level 64
    the Victorious at level 64
    the Steel-hearted at level 64
    the Resolute at level 64
    the Furious at level 66

    That Synchronisation


    That UNBELIEVABLE weekly loot: http://prntscr.com/9j3jd7

    THE POWER OF NON-RUBY PLAYERS:

    http://prntscr.com/9s8yrn
  • Another great report with the calculator by my alliance member:



    King Juvster the Fearless




    PROUD NON-RUBY PLAYER ON INTERNATIONAL1!!!

    Leader of Ghost Marauders on International1 - Level 20 alliance
    http://ghostmarauders.yolasite.com/

    Vice Duke at level 39
    Archduke at level 41
    Prince at level 49
    King at level 53
    the Unyielding at level 55
    the Great at level 56
    the Conqueror at level 59
    the Terrible at level 64
    the Merciless at level 64
    the Victorious at level 64
    the Steel-hearted at level 64
    the Resolute at level 64
    the Furious at level 66

    That Synchronisation


    That UNBELIEVABLE weekly loot: http://prntscr.com/9j3jd7

    THE POWER OF NON-RUBY PLAYERS:

    http://prntscr.com/9s8yrn

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Emoji
Image
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file